Email this article Sulla definizione di cittadino nel libro III della Politica: il metodo di Aristotele tra theoria, empeiria e storia delle praxeis
Abstract
ABSTRACT
On the definition of citizen in book III of Politics: Aristotle’s method between
theoria, empeiria and the history of praxeis
Any attempt to grasp Aristotle’s definition of the citizen in Book III of the Politics necessarily entails reflection on the method of his inquiry. It is method that Aristotle adopts within the domain of political science, and which he accordingly employs when his investigation turns to the citizen as the minimal unit of the city. What deserves particular emphasis is how Aristotle establishes with precision both the object of his inquiry – the polis conceived as a multitude of citizens – and its ultimate purpose: the identification of those who bear political responsibility and exercise sovereign power. The present analysis contends that Aristotle’s treatment cannot be fragmented: the definition of citizenship must be understood within the theoretical framework that hosts it, inseparably bound to the discussion of political responsibility and the sovereignty of citizens. Aristotle takes as his point of departure a contemporary political debate concerning who assumes responsibility for praxeis in the polis, and through this concrete framework develops his theoretical reflection. Close examination reveals the seamless interaction between theoria and empeiria in Aristotle’s procedure: the definition formulated in Chapter 1 undergoes continuous verification through the empirical data and historical cases examined in Chapter 2, notably including practices of colonization and naturalization. The citizen in the unqualified sense (haplos) is defined by the faculty (exousia) of exercising deliberative and judicial functions – functions which qualify participation in the sovereign body (kyrion) of the politeia. This definition retains its validity across different constitutional forms, thereby demonstrating Aristotle’s commitment to grounding theoretical analysis in the observation of actual poleis and their historical praxeis.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFUsage metrics (updated daily, overnight Central European Time)
Article pageviews (filtered): 222
PDF full-text accesses (filtered): 31
References
Accattino 2013
P. Accattino, Aristotele. La Politica. Commento al libro III, in P. Accattino - M. Curnis (a cura di), Aristotele. La Politica. Volume III (libro III), Roma 2013, 147-239.
Anagnostopoulos 2013
G. Anagnostopoulos, Aristotle’s Methods, in G. Anagnostopoulos (ed.), A Companion to Aristotle, Oxford 2013, 101-22.
Arnaoutoglou 2020
I.N. Arnaoutoglou, Η εκμετάλλευση των δημοσίων γαιών στην Λάρισα του ύστερου 3ου αιώνα π.Χ. (Public Land Management in Late Third-Century BC Larissa), EHHD 50 (2020), 37‐85.
Aubenque 2011
P. Aubenque, Aristote et la conception délibérative de la démocratie, in P. Aubenque (éd.), Problèmes Aristotéliciens, Vol. II: Philosophie pratique, Paris 2011, 195-200.
Bartninkas 2014
V. Bartninkas, The Pre-Political and the Political in Aristotle’s Politics, Problemos 85 (2014), 18-29.
Berrón 2020
M. Berrón, Il metodo teorico, aporetico ed empirico nella Politica A di Aristotele, Humanitas 75 (2020), 84-92.
Bearzot 2017
C. Bearzot, Processo decisionale e assunzione di responsabilità nella democrazia ateniese, Hormos 9 (2017), 263-280.
Bertelli 1977
L. Bertelli, Historia e Methodos. Analisi critica e topica politica nel secondo libro della Politica di Aristotele, Torino 1977.
Bertelli 2014
L. Bertelli, Aristotle and History, in G. Parmeggiani (ed.), Between Thucydides and Polybius: The Golden Age of Greek Historiography, Ann Arbor, MI 2014, 289-304.
Bertelli 2017
L. Bertelli, Scienza della politica e politeia in Aristotele, La Parola del Passato 75 (2017), 75-96.
Bertelli 2018a
L. Bertelli, Aristotele democratico?, Teoria politica 8 (2018), 81-103.
Bertelli 2018b
L. Bertelli, Il cittadino in Aristotele: criteri di inclusione/esclusione, in F. de Luise (a cura di), Cittadinanza. Inclusi e esclusi tra gli antichi e i moderni, Trento 2018, 125-164.
Bertelli 2025
L. Bertelli, Metodo o metodi della Politica?, in M. Canevaro - C. Zizza (a cura di), Aristotele. La Politica. Guida, Roma 2025, 73-128.
Bien 1985
G. Bien, La filosofia politica di Aristotele, Bologna 1985.
Blok 2017
J.H. Blok, Citizenship in Classical Athens, Cambridge 2017.
Blok 2018
J. Blok, Retracing Steps: Defining Citizenship in Archaic Greece, in A. Duplouy - R.W. Brock (eds.), Defining Citizenship in Archaic Greece, Oxford 2018, 79-101.
Boffa 2021
G. Boffa, Il giuramento dei fondatori di Cirene (SEG IX, 3), in Riflessioni e spunti per un inquadramento storico e culturale (Themata 23), Tivoli 2021.
Boffo - Faraguna 2021
L. Boffo - M. Faraguna, Le poleis e i loro archivi. Studi su pratiche documentarie, istituzioni e società nell’antichità greca, Trieste 2021.
Cairns 2019
D.L. Cairns, Honour and Kingship in Herodotus: Status, Role, and the Limits of Self-Assertion, Front. Philos. China 14 (2019), 75-93.
Cammack 2020
D. Cammack, Deliberation in Ancient Greek Assemblies, Classical Philology 115 (2020), 486-522.
Canevaro 2023
M. Canevaro, La sovranità della legge come criterio di giudizio costituzionale – tra democrazia e oligarchia. Risposta a Robert Wallace, in Ph. Scheibelreiter (hrsg.), Symposion 2022. Vorträge zur griechischen und hellenistischen Rechtsgeschichte (Gmunden, 21.-25. August 2022), Wien 2023, Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, 131-143.
Criscuolo 2007
L. Criscuolo, Erodoto, Aristotele e la ‘Stele dei fondatori’, in L. Gasperini - S.M. Marengo (a cura di), Cirene e la Cirenaica nell’Antichità. Atti del Convegno internazionale di studi, Tivoli 2007, 187-200.
De Luna 2016
M.E. De Luna, Aristotele. La Politica. Commento al libro V (1-8), in M.E. De Luna - C. Zizza - M. Curnis (a cura di) Aristotele. La Politica, Vol. V: Libri V-VI, Roma 2016, 263-413.
Duplouy 2011
A. Duplouy, Deux échelons de citoyenneté? En quête de la citoyenneté archaïque, in V. Azoulay - P. Ismard (éds.), Clisthène et Lycurgue d’Athènes. Autour du politique dans la cité classique, Paris 2011, 89-106.
Duplouy - Brock 2018
A. Duplouy - R.W. Brock (eds.), Defining Citizenship in Archaic Greece, Oxford 2018.
Faraguna 2024
M. Faraguna, Land and Citizenship in the Greek Polis: Real Property, Public Control, and Institutionalisation, Dike 27 (2024), 121-174.
Faraguna 2025
M. Faraguna, Aristotele, la polis, il cittadino: prospettive storiche e filosofiche, in M. Canevaro - C. Zizza (a cura di), Aristotele. La Politica. Guida, Roma 2025, 215-246.
Filonik 2023
J. Filonik, Sharing in the Polis: Conceptualizing Classical Greek Citizenship, in J. Filonik - C. Plastow - R. Zelnick-Abramovitz (eds.), Citizenship in Antiquity: Civic Communities in the Ancient Mediterranean, London 2023, 264-279.
Frank 2004
J. Frank, Citizens, Slaves, and Foreigners: Aristotle on Human Nature, American Political Science Review 98 (2004), 91-104.
Fröhlich 2016
P. Fröhlich, La citoyenneté grecque entre Aristote et les modernes, CCG 27 (2017), 91-136.
Frullini 2023
S. Frullini, The Language of Citizenship in Herodotus and Thucydides, in J. Filonik - C. Plastow - R. Zelnick-Abramovitz (eds.), Citizenship in Antiquity: Civic Communities in the Ancient Mediterranean, London 2023, 240-249.
Garsten 2013
B. Garsten, Deliberating and Acting Together, in M. Deslauriers - P. Destrée (eds.), The Cambridge Companion to Aristotle’s Politics, Cambridge 2013, 324-49.
Gastaldi 1998
S. Gastaldi, Storia del pensiero politico antico, Roma 1998.
Gastaldi 2018
S. Gastaldi, A chi deve appartenere l’autorità suprema nella città? Il problema del kyrion nella Politica di Aristotele, Teoria politica 8 (2018), 63-79.
Johnson 1984
C.N. Johnson, Who Is Aristotle’s Citizen? Phronesis 29 (1984), 73-90.
Joyce 2023
C. Joyce, Could Athenian Women Be Counted as Citizens in Democratic Athens?, in J. Filonik - C. Plastow - R. Zelnick-Abramovitz (eds.), Citizenship in Antiquity: Civic Communities in the Ancient Mediterranean, London 2023, 342-354.
Landauer 2016
M. Landauer, Democratic Theory and the Athenian Public Sphere, Polis: The Journal for Ancient Greek and Roman Political Thought 33 (2016), 31-51.
Landauer 2019
M. Landauer, Dangerous Counsel: Accountability and Advice in Ancient Greece, Chicago - London 2019.
Lane 2013
M. Lane, Claims to Rule: The Case of the Multitude, in M. Deslauriers - P. Destrée (eds.), The Cambridge Companion to Aristotle’s Politics, Cambridge 2013, 247-274.
Lane 2016
M. Lane, Popular Sovereignty as Control of Office-Holders: Aristotle on Greek Democracy, in R. Bourke - Q. Skinner (eds.), Popular Sovereignty in Historical Perspective, Cambridge 2016, 52-72.
Leszl 1989
W. Leszl, La politica è una ‘techne’? E richiede un’‘episteme’? Uno studio sull’epistemologia nella «Politica» di Aristotele, in E. Berti - M. Napolitano Valditara (a cura di), Etica, Politica, Retorica. Studi su Aristotele e la sua presenza nell’età moderna, L’Aquila 1989, 75-134.
Lévy 1980
E. Lévy, Cité et citoyen dans la Politique d’Aristote, Ktema 5 (1980), 223-248.
Lintott 2018
A. Lintott, Aristotle’s Political Philosophy in Its Historical Context: A New Translation and Commentary on Politics Books 5 and 6, London 2018.
Lloyd 1985
G.E.R. Lloyd, Aristotele. Sviluppo e struttura del suo pensiero, Bologna 1985.
Lockwood c.d.s
Th. Lockwood, In Praise of Solon: Aristotle on Classical Greek Democracy, in E. Robinson - V. Arena (eds.), Cambridge History of Democracy, Cambridge (c.d.s.).
Maffi 2018
A. Maffi, Politeia, politeuma e legislazione nella Politica di Aristotele, Teoria politica 8 (2018), 35-62.
Martin 2012
G. Martin, Kritik am Volk, vor dem Volk: Öffentliche Kommunikation und Konfrontation im klassischen Athen, in Ch. Kuhn (hrsg.), Politische Kommunikation und öffentliche Meinung in der antiken Welt, Stuttgart 2012, 67-85.
Mindus 2014
P. Mindus, Cittadini e no: forme e funzioni dell’inclusione e dell’esclusione, Firenze 2014.
Mindus 2018
P. Mindus, Chi deve essere cittadino? La teoria della cittadinanza nella Politica di Aristotele, Teoria politica 8 (2018), 127-137.
Mosconi 2021
G. Mosconi, Democrazia e buon governo. Cinque tesi democratiche nella Grecia del V secolo a.C., Milano 2021.
Mossé 1979
C. Mossé, Citoyens actifs et citoyens ‘passifs’ dans les cités grecques: une approche théorique du problème, Revue des études anciennes 81 (1979), 241-249.
Mulgan 1977
R.G. Mulgan, Aristotle’s Political Theory, Oxford 1977.
Mulgan 1990
R.G. Mulgan, Aristotle and the Value of Political Participation, Political Theory 18 (1990), 195-215.
Mulgan 1991
R.G. Mulgan, Aristotle’s Analysis of Oligarchy and Democracy, in D. Keyt - F.D. Miller, Jr. (eds.), A Companion to Aristotle’s Politics, Oxford 1991, 307-322.
Müller 2014
C. Müller, La (dé)construction de la politeia: citoyenneté et octroi de privilèges aux étrangers dans les démocraties hellénistiques, Annales (HSS) 69 (2014), 753-775.
Nagle 2006
D.B. Nagle, The Household as the Foundation of Aristotle’s Polis, Cambridge 2006.
Natali 2020
C. Natali, La définition du citoyen chez Aristote, Politique III, Revue de Philosophie Ancienne 38.2 (2020): Aristote, les définitions en philosophie pratique, éd. par P.M. Morel - C. Natali, 339-366.
Newman 1902
W.L. Newman, The Politics of Aristotle. Two essays; Books III, IV, and V: Text and Notes, Vol. 3, Oxford 1902.
Ober 1998
J. Ober, Political Dissent in Democratic Athens: Intellectual Critics of Popular Rule, Princeton 1998.
Pasini 2016
G. Pasini, Le considerazioni dell’oratore Demostene sui meccanismi decisionali collettivi nell’Atene del IV sec. a.C., Rivista Italiana di Filosofia del Linguaggio/BC (2016), 199-218.
Patterson 2005
C. Patterson, Athenian Citizenship Law, in M. Gagarin - D. Cohen (eds.), A Companion to Ancient Greek Law, Cambridge 2005, 267-289.
Peels 2017
S. Peels, Notes on IG IX 1 (2) 3: 718 (Foundation Decree of Locrian Colony at Naupactus), ZPE 201 (2017), 110-116.
Pellegrin 2018
P. Pellegrin, Aristotle and Democracy, in D. Sfendoni-Mentzou (ed.), Aristotle Contemporary Perspectives on His Thought: On the 2400th Anniversary of Aristotle’s Birth, Berlin - Boston 2018, 197-210.
Poddighe 2014
E. Poddighe, Aristotele, Atene e le metamorfosi dell’idea democratica. Da Solone a Pericle (594-451 a.C.), Roma 2014.
Poddighe 2016
E. Poddighe, Giustizia e costituzione: scienza politica e intelligibilità della storia secondo Aristotele (EN, V, 1134a 25 - 1135a 8), Gerión 34 (2016), 77-101.
Poddighe 2023
E. Poddighe, Politica e democrazia nella riflessione di Aristotele sulla cittadinanza. Il contributo di Leo Strauss, in C. Fornis - M. García Sánchez - L. Sancho Rocher (coord.), La democracia griega y sus intérpretes en la tradición occidental, Madrid 2023, 471-504.
Poddighe 2024
E. Poddighe, Il problema della responsabilità politica nella discussione di Aristotele sulla cittadinanza, in L. Sancho Rocher - M. García Sánchez (coord.), Democracias, ley e instituciones (antiguas y modernas), Madrid 2024, 139-163.
Poddighe 2025
E. Poddighe, Aristotele e la cittadinanza dei teti nell’Atene soloniana: la comparsa e lo sviluppo del tema nella Politica, in M.E. De Luna (a cura di), La polis, l’ethos, il pathos e il logos. Ricerche di filosofia pratica aristotelica, Milano 2025.
Rapp 2020
Ch. Rapp, Definitions in Aristotle’s Politics, in P.M. Morel - C. Natali (eds.), Revue de Philosophie Ancienne 38.2 (2020), 367-409.
Riesbeck 2016
D.J. Riesbeck, Aristotle on Political Community, Cambridge 2016.
Robinson 1995
R. Robinson, Aristotle’s Politics: Books III and IV. Translated with Introduction and Comments by R. Robinson. With a Supplementary Essay by D. Keyt, Oxford 1995 (trad. it. R. Robinson, Aristotele, Politica, commento ai libri III-IV, in R. Radice - T. Gargiulo [trad. a cura di], Aristotele, Politica, Vol. I: Libri I-IV, Milano 2014, 424-466).
Rosamilia 2023
E. Rosamilia, La città del silfio. Istituzioni, culti ed economia di Cirene classica ed ellenistica attraverso le fonti epigrafiche, Pisa 2023.
Rubinstein 1998
L. Rubinstein, The Athenian Political Perception of the Idiotes, in P. Cartledge - P. Millar - S. von Reden (eds.), Kosmos: Essays in Order, Conflict and Community in Classical Athens, Cambridge 1998, 125-143.
Salviat - Vatin 1974
F. Salviat - C. Vatin, Le cadastre de Larissa, BCH 98 (1974), 247-262.
Samaras 2015
Th. Samaras, Aristotle and the Question of Citizenship, in Th. Lockwood - Th. Samaras (eds.), Aristotle’s Politics: A Critical Guide, Cambridge 2015, 123-141.
Samaras 2016
Th. Samaras, The Best City in Aristotle’s Politics, Philosophical Inquiry 40 (2016), 131-145.
Schipani - Ferraioli 2023
B. Schipani - F. Ferraioli, Granting Citizenship to Women in Ancient Epirus 1, in J. Filonik - C. Plastow - R. Zelnick-Abramovitz (eds.), Citizenship in Antiquity: Civic Communities in the Ancient Mediterranean, London 2023, 198-208.
Schofield 1999
M. Schofield, Saving the City: Philosopher Kings and Other Classical Paradigms, London - New York 1999.
Schofield 2011
M. Schofield, Aristotle and the Democratization of Politics, in B. Morison - K. Ierodiakonou (eds.), Episteme: Essays in Honour of Jonathan Barnes, Oxford 2011, 285-301.
Schütrumpf 1991
E. Schütrumpf, Aristoteles, Politik Buch II/III, Berlin 1991.
Simonton 2017
M. Simonton, Classical Greek Oligarchy: A Political History, Princeton 2017.
Simpson 1998
P.L.P. Simpson, A Philosophical Commentary on the Politics of Aristotle, Chapel Hill - London 1998.
Strauss 1964
L. Strauss, The City and Man, Chicago 1964.
Strauss 1967
L. Strauss, Aristotle’s Politics.
https://archive.org/details/Aristotle_201402/Strauss%200Aristotle%27s%20Politics%20%5B1967%5D/
Strauss 2010
L. Strauss, La città e l’uomo: saggi su Aristotele, Platone, Tucidide. A cura di C. Altini, Genova - Milano 2010 (The City and Man, Chicago 1964).
Tordesillas 2013
A. Tordesillas, Aristotele, Gorgia e i mortai di Larissa, in C. Rossitto - A. Coppola - F. Biasutti (a cura di), Aristotele e la storia, Padova 2013, 139-155.
Touloumakos 1985
J. Touloumakos, Die theoretische Begründung der Demokratie in der klassischen Zeit Griechenlands, Athens 1985.
Viano 2002
C.A. Viano (a cura di), Aristotele. La Politica, Milano 2002.
Whitehead 1991
D. Whitehead, Norms of Citizenship in Ancient Greece, in A. Molho - K. Raaflaub - J. Emlen (eds.), Athens and Rome, Florence and Venice: City-States in Classical Antiquity and Medieval Italy, Stuttgart 1991, 135-154.
Winthrop 1975
D. Winthrop, Aristotle and Political Responsibility, Political Theory 3 (1975), 406-422.
Winthrop 2019
D. Winthrop, Aristotle: Democracy and Political Science, Chicago - London 2019.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7358/erga-2025-002-pode
Copyright (©) 2026 Elisabetta Poddighe – Editorial format and Graphical layout: copyright (©) LED Edizioni Universitarie
This work is published on this website under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Announcements
Erga/Logoi accepts books for review
The books are to be sent to the Executive Editor
Call for papers Vol. 16 (2028)
Authors have to read through the Information for Authors and the Author guidelines carefully before beginning the submission process.
Erga-Logoi. Rivista di storia, letteratura, diritto e culture dell'antichità
Registered by Tribunale di Milano (20/09/2012 n. 353)
Online ISSN 2282-3212 - Print ISSN 2280-9678
Direttore responsabile: Cinzia Bearzot
Editors-in-Chief: Cinzia Bearzot, Paolo A. Tuci
Editorial Staff: Marcello Bertoli - Livia De Martinis - Laura Loddo - Alessandra Valentini
Editorial Board: Gaetano Arena - Christopher A. Baron - Ralf Behrwald - Margherita Cassia - Paolo Cesaretti - Michele Faraguna - Massimo Gioseffi - Dominique Lenfant - Lauretta Maganzani - Roberto Nicolai - Giovanni Parmeggiani - Marina Polito - Umberto Roberto - Francesca Rohr - Marco Sannazaro - Stefan Schorn - Sławomir Sprawski - Paolo A. Tuci - Gianpaolo Urso - José Vela Tejada
Emeritus Editorial Board: Serena Bianchetti - Giovannella Cresci - Lia Raffaella Cresci - Ugo Fantasia - Franca Landucci - Rosalia Marino - Riccardo Vattuone - Robert Wallace
© 2001-2026 LED Edizioni Universitarie di Lettere Economia Diritto