Led On Line
Presentazione - About us
Novita' - What's new
E-Journals
E-books
Lededizioni Home Page Ricerca - Search
Catalogo - Catalogue
Per contattarci - Contacts
Per gli Autori - For the Authors
Statistiche - Statistics
Cookie Policy
Privacy Policy

The Challenges of Legal Translation in Multilingual Contexts

Valentina Jacometti

Abstract


The increasing multilateralism in international relations has led to the spreading of the principle of official multilingualism within the international and supranational organizations, which involves the need to produce legal texts in multiple languages. This paper aims to highlight the features of multilingual legal drafting within different contexts: first, within national legal systems, such as Canada and Switzerland; second, within international organizations, with particular attention to multilingual treaties and taking as paradigmatic example the United Nations’ activity; and third, within the European Union, highlighting the complexity of the multilingual legislative drafting in view of the independent, multilingual and directly applicable nature of EU law. These contexts are profoundly different in various ways, such as the reasons and the legal basis of multilingualism and the criteria and methods of drafting, adopting and interpreting multilingual legal texts.


Keywords


co-drafting; international and supranational organizations; legal translation; multilingual legal drafting; multilingual states.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Akehurst, M., “Preparing the Authentic Text of the E.E.C. Treaty”, in Wortley, B. A. (ed.), An Introduction to the Law of the European Economic Community, Oceana Publications, 1972, 20 ff.

Bar, S., “La Question des Langues au Sein des Nations Unies”, in Guillorel, H., Koubi, G. (éd.), Langues et Droits, Bruylant, 1999, 291 sq.

Beaudoin, L., “Legal Translation in Canada: the Genius of Legal Language(s)”, in Olsen, F., Lorz, R., Stein, D. (eds.), Translation Issues in Language and Law, Palgrave Macmillan, 2009, 136 ff.

Bergeron, M., “La traduction juridique au Canada”, in Astti/Eti, La traduction juridique: histoire, théorie(s) et pratique, Astti/Eti, 2000.

Berteloot, P., “Der Rahmen juristischer Übersetzung”, in de Groot, G.R., Schulze, R. (hrg.), Recht und Übersetzen, Nomos, 1999, 101 ff.

Cao, D., Translating Law, Multilingual Matters, 2007.

Cao, D., Zhao, X., “Translation at the United Nations as Specialized Translation”, in The Journal of Specialised Translation, 2008, 39 ff.

Cashin-Ritaine, E., “L’expérience de l’Institut Suisse de droit compare”, in Cornu, M., Moreau, M. (éd.), Traduction du Droit et Droit de la Traduction, Dalloz, 2011, 61 sq.

Correia, R., “Translation of EU Legal Texts”, in Tosi, A. (ed.), Crossing Barriers and Bridging Cultures. The Challenges of Multilingual Translation for European Union, Multilingual Matters, 2003, 38 ff.

Cosmai D., The Language of Europe. Multilingualism and Translation in the EU Institutions: Practice, Problems and Perspective, Editions de l'Université de Bruxelles, 2014.

Creech, R.L., Law and Language in the European Union, Europa Law Publishing, 2005.

Dannemann G., “System Neutrality in Legal Translation”, in Pasa, B., Morra, L. (eds.), Translating the DCFR and Drafting the CESL, A Pragmatic Perspective, Sellier European Law Publisher, 2014, 119 ff.

Denza, E., “Compromise and Clarity in International Drafting”, in Stefanou, C., Xanthaki, H. (ed.), Drafting Legislation. A Modern Approach, Ashgate, 2008, 231 ff.

Doczekalska, A., “Drafting or Translation – Production of Multilingual Legal Texts”, in Olsen, F., Lorz, R., Stein, D. (eds.), Translation Issues in Language and Law, Palgrave Macmillan, 2009, 116 ff.

Doczekalska, A., “Production and application of multilingual law: the principle of equality of authentic texts and the value of subsequent translation”, in Kredens, K., Gozdz-Roszkowski, S. (eds.), Language and the Law: International Outlooks, Peter Lang, 2007, 57 ff.

Doetsch, A., “La corédaction des lois canadiennes: historique, pratcique, apports”, in Cornu M., Moreau M. (éd.), Traduction du Droit et Droit de la Traduction, Dalloz, 2011, 51 ff.

Gallas, T., “Drafting multilingue: missione impossibile”, in Ioriatti Ferreri, E. (cur.), La traduzione del diritto comunitario ed europeo: riflessioni metodologiche, Università degli Studi di Trento, 2007, 27 ss.

Gambaro, A., “Interpretation of Multilingual Legislative Texts”, in Boele-Woelki, K., van Erp, S. (eds.), General reports of the 17. Congress of the International academy of comparative law, 2007, 51 ff.

Gémar, J.-C., “Le discours du législateur en situation multilingue: Traduire ou corédiger les lois?”, in LeGes, 2001, 13 sq.

Ioriatti, E., “Linguistic Precedent and Nomadic Meanings in EC Private Law”, in Revista general de derecho publico comparado, 2009.

Ivrakis, S.C., ““Official Translations” of International Instruments; Practice of the ILO, the LN and the UN”, in Revue hellènique de droit international, 1955, 213 ff.

KJær, A.L., “Legal translation at the European Union: A research field in need for a new approach”, in Kredens, K., Gozdz-Roszkowski, S. (eds.), Language and the Law: International Outlooks, Peter Lang, 2007, 69 ff.

Labelle, A., “La corédaction des lois fédérales au Canada. Vingt ans après: quelques réflexions”, in Astti/Eti, La traduction juridique: histoire, théorie(s) et pratique, Astti/Eti, 2000.

Lautissier G., “La législation de l’Union européenne: une règle unique en vingt-trois langues”, in Cornu, M., Moreau, M.(éd.), Traduction du Droit et Droit de la Traduction, Dalloz, 2011, 89 sq.

Lӧtscher, A., “Multilingual law drafting in Switzerland”, in Grewendorf, G., Rathert, M. (eds.), Formal Linguistics and the Law, Mouton de Gruyter, 2009, 371 ff.

Megale, F., Teorie della traduzione giuridica. Fra diritto comparato e Translation Studies, Editoriale Scientifica, 2008.

Nelson, L.D.M., “The Drafting Committee of the Third United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea: the Implications of Multilingual Texts”, in British Yearbook of International Law, 1987, 169 ff.

Pozzo, B. and Jacometti, V. (eds), Multilingualism and the Harmonisation of European law. Kluwer Law International, 2006.

Pozzo, B., “English as a Lingua Franca in the EU Multilingual Context”, in Baaij, C.J.W., The Role of Legal Translation in Legal Harmonisation, Kluwer Law International, 2012, 183 ff.

Revell D. L., “The Canadian Experience: the Importance of Process”, in Brooklyn J. Int'l L., 2004, 1085 ff.

Robinson, W., “How the European Commission drafts legislation in 20 languages”, in Clarity, 2005, 53 ff.

Rosenne, S., “The Meaning of “Authentic Text” in Modern Treaty Law”, in Bernhardt, R. et al. (hrg.), Festschrift für Hermann Mosler, Springer, 1983, 759 ff.

Šarčevič S., “Translation Procedures for Legal Translators”, in Šarčevič, S. (ed.), Legal Translation – Preparation for Accession to the European Union, Faculty of Law, University of Rijeka, 2001, 75 ff.

Šarčevič, S. (ed.), Language and Culture in EU Law, 2015.

Šarčevič, S., “The Quest for Legislative Bilinguism and Multilingualism: Co-drafting in Canada and Switzerland”, in Gémar, J.-C., Kasirer, N. (eds.), Jurilinguistique: entre langues et droits - Jurilinguistics: Between Law and Language, Thémis/Bruylant, 2005, 277 ff.

Šarčevič, S., New Approach to Legal Translation, Kluwer Law Intl, 2000.

Tabory, M., Multilingualism in International Law and Institutions, Springer Netherlands, 1980.

United Nations, “Preparation of Multilingual Treaties: Memorandum by the Secretariat”, in Yearbook of the International Law Commission, II, 1996, 104 ff.

Wagner, E., “Producing multilingual legislation in Switzerland”, in Clarity, 2005, 18 ff.

Wagner, E., Bech, S. and Martínez, J.M., Translating for the European Union Institutions, 2 ed. Routledge, 2014.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.7358/lcm-2020-001-jaco

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

 


Lingue Culture Mediazioni - Languages Cultures Mediation
Registered by Tribunale di Milano (27/11/2013 n. 380)
Online ISSN 2421-0293 - Print ISSN 2284-1881


Dipartimento di Scienze della Mediazione Linguistica e di Studi Interculturali
Università degli Studi di Milano


Editors-in-Chief: Paola Catenaccio, Giuliana Garzone
Editors:  Marina Brambilla, Luigi Bruti Liberati, Maria Vittoria Calvi, Gabriella Cartago, Lidia De Michelis, Dino Gavinelli, Marie-Christine Jullion, Alessandra Lavagnino, Chiara Molinari, Giovanni Turchetta.
Sub-Editors: Maria Matilde Benzoni, Paola Cotta Ramusino, Mario De Benedittis, Kim Grego, Giovanna Mapelli, Fabio Mollica, Bettina Marta Mottura, Mauro Giacomo Novelli, Letizia Osti, Maria Cristina Paganoni, Giuseppe Sergio, Virginia Sica, Nicoletta Vallorani.
International Advisory Board: James Archibald (Translation Studies) - Hugo de Burgh (Chinese Media Studies) - Kristen Brustad (Arabic Linguistics) - Daniel Coste (French Language) - Luciano Curreri (Italian Literature) - Claudio Di Meola (German Linguistics) - Donatella Dolcini (Hindi Studies) - Johann Drumbl (German Linguistics) - Denis Ferraris (Italian Literature) - Lawrence Grossberg (Cultural Studies) - Stephen Gundle (Film and Television Studies) - Tsuchiya Junji (Sociology) - John McLeod (Post-colonial Studies) - Estrella Montolío Durán (Spanish Language) - Silvia Morgana (Italian Linguistics) - Samir Marzouki (Translation, Cultural Relations) - Mbare Ngom (Post-Colonial Literatures) - Christiane Nord (Translation Studies) - Roberto Perin (History) - Giovanni Rovere (Italian Linguistics) - Lara Ryazanova-Clarke (Russian Studies) - Shi-Xu (Discourse and Cultural Studies) - Srikant Sarangi (Discourse analysis) - Françoise Sabban, Centre d'études sur la Chine moderne et contemporaine (Chinese Studies) - Itala Vivan (Cultural Studies, Museum Studies)

Editor of LCM - The Series: Marie-Christine Jullion


Referee List