Led On Line
Presentazione - About us
Novita' - What's new
E-Journals
E-books
Lededizioni Home Page Ricerca - Search
Catalogo - Catalogue
Per contattarci - Contacts
Per gli Autori - For the Authors
Statistiche - Statistics
Cookie Policy
Privacy Policy

Refusing Help and Inflicting Harm. A Critique of the Environmentalist View

Eze Paez

Abstract


Due to a variety of natural causes, suffering predominates over well-being in the lives of wild animals. From an antispeciesist standpoint that considers the interests of all sentient individuals, we should intervene in nature to benefit these animals, provided that the expectable result is net positive. However, according to the environmentalist view the aim of benefiting wild animals cannot justify intervening in nature. In addition, harmful human interventions can sometimes be justified. This view assumes that (i) certain entities such as ecosystems or species have intrinsic value, and that (ii) at least sometimes these values are more important than nonhuman well-being. In this article I review the arguments in support of this view advanced by three prominent environmentalists (Albert Schweitzer, Paul W. Taylor and J. Baird Callicott) and show how none of them succeed at grounding these assumptions.


Keywords


animal ethics; antispeciesism; environmentalism; biocentrism; ecocentrism; nonhuman animals; intrinsic value; intervention in nature; wild animals; natural harms

Full Text:

PDF

References


Callicott, J. Baird (1989) “Intrinsic Value, Quantum Theory, and Environmental Ethics”, in J. Baird Callicott, In Defense of tile Land Ethic: Essays in Environmental Philosophy, Albany: State University of New York Press.

Cowen, Tyler (2003) “Policing Nature”, Environmental Ethics, 25, 169-182.

Dunayer, Joan (2004) Speciesism, Derwood: Ryce.

Faria, Catia (2012) “Muerte entre las flores: el conflicto entre el ecologismo y la defensa de los animales no humanos”, Viento Sur, 125, 67-76.

Faria, Catia and Paez, Eze (2014) “Anthropocentrism and speciesism: conceptual and normative issues”, Revista de Bioética y Derecho, 32, 82-90.

Horta, Oscar (2010a) “Disvalue in Nature and Intervention”, Pensata Animal, 34.

Horta, Oscar (2010b) “Debunking the Idyllic View of Natural Processes: Population Dynamics and Suffering in the Wild”, Télos, 17, 73-88.

Horta, Oscar (2010c) “What Is Speciesism?”, Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 23, 243-266.

Horta, Oscar (2010d) “The Ethics of the Ecology of Fear against the Nonspeciesist Paradigm: A Shift in the Aims of Intervention in Nature”, Between the Species, 10, 163-187.

McMahan, Jeff (2010) “The Meat Eaters”, The New York Times, 19 September 2010, http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/09/19/the-meat-eaters/

Ng, Yew-Kwang (1995) “Towards Welfare Biology: Evolutionary Economics of Animal Consciousness and Suffering”, Biology and Philosophy, 10 (3), 255-285.

Nussbaum, Martha C. (2006) Frontiers of Justice: Disability, Nationality, Species Membership, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Pluhar, Evelyn B. (1995) Beyond Prejudice: The Moral Significance of Human and Nonhuman Animals, Durham: Duke University Press.

Sapontzis, Stephen (1984). “Predation”, Ethics and Animals, 5, 27-38.

Schweitzer, Albert (1994) Civilization and Ethics, in A. Naish (trans.) Environmental Ethics: Readings in Theory and Application, Boston: Jones and Bartlett.

Taylor, Paul W. (1986) Respect for Nature: A Theory of Environmental Ethics, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Tomasik, Brian (2014) “The Importance of Wild Animal Suffering”, Foundational Research Institute, http://foundational-research.org/publications/importance-of-wild-animal-suffering




DOI: https://doi.org/10.7358/rela-2015-002-paez




___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Relations. Beyond Anthropocentrism
Registered by Tribunale di Milano (04/05/2012 n. 211)
Online ISSN 2280-9643 - Print ISSN 2283-3196
___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Executive Editor: Matteo Andreozzi
Managing Editor: Adele Tiengo
Associate Editors: Rod Bennison - Alma Massaro - Kim Stallwood - Jessica Ulrich
Consulting Editor: Leonardo Caffo
Review Editors: Sofia Bonicalzi - Eleonora Adorni
Editorial Board: Ralph R. Acampora - Carol J. Adams - Matthew R. Calarco - Gabriele Cambiotti - Piergiorgio Donatelli - Arianna Ferrari - William Grove-Fanning - Serenella Iovino - Joel MacClellan - Dario Martinelli - Roberto Marchesini - Barbara Muraca - Serpil Oppermann - Piergiacomo Pagano - Paola Sobbrio - Sabrina Tonutti