Email this article Once Again on Aristotle and the Identity of the Athenian Nomothetai. A Response to Gertrud Dietze-Mager
Abstract
This article is a short response to a recent contribution by Dietze-Mager in Erga-Logoi 10.2. There, within a larger discussion of the reliability of the Aristotelian Athenaion Politeia as a historical source, Dietze-Mager argues against our proposed identification of the Athenian nomothetai with a special session of the Assembly. In response, we start with a concise summary of our interpretation of the constitutional stages in the Athenaion Politeia in light of the socio-economic methodology of Politics IV, and clarify the role of Aristotle’s political theory in our reconstruction. We then provide a close reading of some key evidence about the identity of the Athenian nomothetai (particularly Aeschin. III 38-40). We demonstrate that Dietze-Mager’s proposed reading of the relevant passage is linguistically and syntactically problematic, arguing that the only possible interpretation of the relevant procedure as described at Aeschin. III 38-40 involves identifying the nomothetai with a special lawmaking session of the Assembly.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Accattino 1986
P. Accattino, L'anatomia della città nella «Politica» di Aristotele, Torino 1986.
Bearzot 2007
C. Bearzot, I nomophylakes in due lemmi di Polluce, in C. Bearzot - F. Landucci Gattinoni - G. Zecchini (a cura di), L'«Onomasticon» di Giulio Polluce: tra lessicografia e antiquaria, Milano 2007, 43-68.
Bearzot 2012
C. Bearzot, Nomophylakes e nomophylakia nella Politica di Aristotele, in M. Polito - C. Talamo (a cura di), Istituzioni e costituzioni in Aristotele tra storiografia e pensiero politico, Tivoli 2012, 29-47.
Bertelli 1993
L. Bertelli, La 'costituzione di Atene' era una democrazia?, in L.R. Cresci - L. Piccirilli (a cura di), L'«Athenaion Politeia» di Aristotele, Genova 1993, 53-98.
Bertelli 1994
L. Bertelli, Democrazia e Metabolé. Rapporti tra l'Athenaion Politeia e la teoria politica di Aristotele, in G.F. Maddoli (a cura di), L'«Athenaion Politeia» di Aristotele, 1891-1991. Per un bilancio di cento anni di studi, Perugia 1994, 71-99.
Bertelli 2018
L. Bertelli, The Athenaion Politeia and Aristotle's Political Theory, in M. Canevaro - C. Bearzot - E. Poddighe - T. Gargiulo (a cura di), «Athenaion Politeiai» tra storia, sociologia e politica: Aristotele e Pseudo-Senofonte, Milano 2018, 71-86.
Besso et al. 2014
G. Besso - M. Canevaro - M. Curnis - F. Pezzoli (a cura di), Aristotele, La «Politica». Libro IV, Roma 2014.
Bloch 1940
H. Bloch, Studies on Historical Literature of the Fourth Century B.C., HSCPh 51.1 (1940): Athenian Studies Presented to W.S. Ferguson, 303-376.
Boas et al. 2019
E. van Emde Boas - A. Rijksbaron - L. Huitink - M. de Bakker, The Cambridge Grammar of Classical Greek, Cambridge 2019.
https://doi.org/10.1017/9781139027052
Bonifazi - Drummen - de Kreij 2016
A. Bonifazi - A. Drummen - M. de Kreij, Particles in Ancient Greek Discourse: Exploring Particle Use across Genres (Hellenic Studies Series 79), Washington, DC 2016.
Canevaro 2013a
M. Canevaro, Nomothesia in Classical Athens: What Sources Should We Believe?, CQ 63 (2013), 1-22.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009838812000560
Canevaro 2013b
M. Canevaro, The Documents in the Attic Orators: Laws and Decrees in the Public Speeches of the Demosthenic Corpus, Oxford 2013.
https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199668908.001.0001
Canevaro 2013c
M. Canevaro, The Twilight of Nomothesia: Legislation in Early-Hellenistic Athens (322-301), Dike 14 (2013), 59-92.
Canevaro 2015
M. Canevaro, Making and Changing Laws in Ancient Athens, in E.M. Harris - M. Canevaro (eds.), Oxford Handbook of Ancient Greek Law, Oxford 2015.
https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199599257.013.4
Canevaro 2016a
M. Canevaro, The Procedure of Demosthenes' Against Leptines: How to Repeal (and Replace) an Existing Law, JHS 136 (2016), 39-58.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0075426916000045
Canevaro 2016b
M. Canevaro (a cura di), Demostene, «Contro Leptine». Introduzione, traduzione e commento storico, Berlin 2016.
https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110497267
Canevaro 2018
M. Canevaro, The Authenticity of the Document at Dem. 24.20-3, the Procedures of Nomothesia and the So-Called ἐπιχɛιροτονία τῶν νόμων, Klio 100.1 (2018), 70-124.
https://doi.org/10.1515/klio-2018-0003
Canevaro 2019a
M. Canevaro, Athenian Constitutionalism: Nomothesia and Graphe Nomon me Epitedeion Theinai, in G. Thür - U. Yiftach - R. Zelnick-Abramovitz (hrsgg.), Symposion 2017: Vorträge zur griechischen und hellenistischen Rechtsgeschichte, Wien 2019, 65-98.
https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctvd7w7mm.9
Canevaro 2019b
M. Canevaro, La deliberation démocratique à l'Assemblée athénienne. Procedures et strategies de legitimation, Annales HSS 74.2 (2019), 339-381.
https://doi.org/10.1017/ahss.2020.8
Canevaro 2019c
M. Canevaro, Nomothesia e amministrazione finanziari: frammenti eigrafici di 'costitutizionalizzazione' e sviluppo istituzionale dell'Atene di IV secolo, Historika 9 (2019), 485-524.
Canevaro 2020
M. Canevaro, On Dem. 24.20-23 and the So-Called ἐπιχειροτονία τῶν νόμων: Some Final Clarifications in Response to M. H. Hansen, Klio 102.1 (2020), 26-35.
https://doi.org/10.1515/klio-2020-0002
Canevaro 2022
M. Canevaro, Social Mobility v. Societal Stability: Once Again on the Aims and Meaning of Solon's Reforms, in J.C. Bernhardt - M. Canevaro (eds.), From Homer to Solon: Continuity and Change in Archaic Greece, Leiden 2022, 363-413.
Canavero - Esu 2018
M. Canevaro - A. Esu, Extreme Democracy and Mixed Constitution in Theory and Practice: Nomophylakia and Fourth-Century Nomothesia in the Aristotelian Athenaion Politeia, in M. Canevaro - C. Bearzot - E. Poddighe - T. Gargiulo (a cura di), «Athenaion Politeiai» tra storia, politica e sociologia: Aristotele e Pseudo-Senofonte, Milano 2018, 105-145.
Carawan 2016
E. Carawan, Documents in the Case: Demosthenes 23-24, TAPA 146.1 (2016), 37-60.
https://doi.org/10.1353/apa.2016.a619100
Carawan 2020
E. Carawan, Control of the Laws in the Ancient Democracy at Athens, Baltimore 2020.
https://doi.org/10.1353/book.79378
de Bruyn 1995
O. de Bruyn, La competence de l'Aréopage en matière de process publics: des origins de la polis athénienne à la conquête romaine de la Grèce (vers 700-146 avant J.-C.), Stuttgart 1995.
Denniston 1954
J.D. Denniston, The Greek Particles, 2nd ed., rev. K.J. Dover, London 1954.
Dietze-Mager 2021
G. Dietze-Mager, Das Konzept des sozialen Friedens und seine Widersprüche. Ein Beitrag zu Aristoteles' argumentativer und historischer Glaubwürdigkeit, Histos 15 (2021), 52-87.
Dietze-Mager 2022
G. Dietze-Mager, Aristoteles und die Kunst des Verschweigens. Die aristotelische Darstellung von demokratischer Bürgerrechtsverleihung, Areopag und nomothesia im Licht externer Quellen, Erga-Logoi 10.2 (2022), 7-58.
https://doi.org/10.7358/erga-2022-002-gdie
Esu 2020
A. Esu, After the Empire: Judicial Review and Athenian Interstate Relations in the Age of Demosthenes, 354-22 BCE, in E. Cavanagh (ed.), Empire and Legal Thought: Ideas and Institutions from Antiquity to Modernity, Leiden 2020, 69-104.
https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004431249_004
Esu 2021a
A. Esu, Review of Carawan 2020, BMCR 12.33 (2021).
https://bmcr.brynmawr.edu/2021/2021.12.33/
https://doi.org/10.12968/nuwa.2021.12.33
Esu 2021b
A. Esu, Adeia in Fifth-Century Athens, JHS 141 (2021), 153-178.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0075426921000100
Esu c.d.s.
A. Esu, Divided Power in Ancient Greece: Decision-Making and Institutions in the Classical and Hellenistic Polis, Oxford c.d.s.
Faraguna 2016
M. Faraguna, Antifonte, il processo per tradimento e gli archivi ateniesi, in S. Struffolino (a cura di), Ἡμέτερα γράμματα. Scritti di epigrafia greca offerti a Teresa Alfieri Tonini, Milano 2016, 67-92.
Gehrke 1978
H.-J. Gehrke, Das Verhältnis von Politik und Philosophie im Wirken des Demetrios von Phaleron, Chiron 8 (1978), 149-193.
Hansen 1987
M.H. Hansen, The Athenian Assembly in the Age of Demosthenes, Oxford 1987.
Hansen 1991
M.H. Hansen, The Athenian Democracy in the Age of Demosthenes, London 1991.
Hansen 2016
M.H. Hansen, The Authenticity of the Law about Nomothesia Inserted in Demosthenes Against Timokrates 20-23, GRBS 56.3 (2016), 438-474.
Harris 2013
E.M. Harris, The Rule of Law in Action in Democratic Athens, Oxford 2013.
https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199899166.001.0001
Harris 2016
E.M. Harris, From Democracy to Rule of Law? Constitutional Changes in Athens during the Fifth and the Fourth Century BCE, in C. Tiersch (hrsg.), Die athenische Demokratie im 4. Jahrhundert. Zwischen Modernisierung und Tradition, Stuttgart 2016, 73-87.
Harris 2019
E.M. Harris, Aeschylus' Eumenides: The Role of the Areopagus, the Rule of Law and Political Discourse in Attic Tragedy, in A. Markantonatos - E. Volonaki (eds.), Poet and Orator: A Symbiotic Relationship in Democratic Athens, Berlin - Boston 2019, 389-420.
https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110629729-019
Harris 2021
E.M. Harris, Review of Carawan 2020, Classical Philology 117.3 (2021), 567-575.
https://doi.org/10.1086/720209
Harris 2022
E.M. Harris, Notes on the New Law of Epicrates from the Athenian Agora, ZPE 222 (2022), 65-81.
Harris - Esu 2021
E.M. Harris - A. Esu, Policing Major Crimes in Classical Athens: Eisangelia and Other Public Procedures, Rivista di diritto ellenico 11 (2021), 39-119.
Knox 1975
R.A. Knox (ed.), Aeschines, «Against Ctesiphon». Sections 1-78: A Literary and Historical Commentary, Oxford 1975 (DPhil Diss.).
Martin - de Budé 1928
V. Martin - G. de Budé (éds.), Discours II. «Contre Ctesiphon». «Lettres», Paris 1928.
Mathieu - Haussoulier 1922
G. Mathieu - B. Haussoulier (éds.), Aristote, «Constitution d'Athènes», Paris 1922.
Piérart 2000
M. Piérart, Qui étaient les nomothètes à Athènes à l'époque de Démosthène?, in E. Lèvy (éd.), La codification des lois dans l'antiquité, Paris 2000, 229-256.
Rhodes 1981
P.J. Rhodes, A Commentary on the Aristotelian «Athenaion Politeia», Oxford 1981.
Rhodes 1984
P.J. Rhodes, Nomothesia in Fourth-Century Athens, CQ 35 (1984), 55-60.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009838800014567
Rhodes 1987
P.J. Rhodes, Nomothesia in Classical Athens, L'educazione giuridica 5.2 (1987), 5-26.
Rhodes 2003
P.J. Rhodes, Sessions of Nomothetai in Fourth-Century Athens, CQ 53 (2003), 124-129.
https://doi.org/10.1093/cq/53.1.124
Rhodes 2017
P.J. Rhodes, The «Athenian Constitution» Written in the School of Aristotle. Edited with an Introduction, Translation and Commentary, Liverpool 2017.
Richardson 2021
M.B. Richardson, The Law of Epikrates of 354/3 B.C., Hesperia 90.4 (2021), 685-746.
https://doi.org/10.2972/hesperia.90.4.0685
Rohde 2019
D. Rohde, Von der Deliberationsdemokratie zur Zustimmungsdemokratie. Die öffentlichen Finanzen Athens und die Ausbildung einer Kompetenzelite im 4. Jahrhundert v. Chr., Stuttgart 2019.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-476-04698-7
Saldutti 2022
V. Saldutti, The Mixed Constitution of Demetrius Phalereus, Klio 104.1 (2022), 159-190.
https://doi.org/10.1515/klio-2021-0038
Schöll 1886
R. Schöll, Über attische Gesetzgebung, SBAW, Munich 1886, 83-139.
Sealey 1987
R. Sealey, The Athenian Republic: Democracy or Rule of Law?, University Park - London 1987.
Stroud 1998
R.S. Stroud, The Athenian Grain-Tax Law of 374/3 B.C. (Hesperia Suppl. 29), Princeton 1998.
https://doi.org/10.2307/1354031
Wallace 1989
R.W. Wallace, The Areopagus Council to 307 B.C., Baltimore - London 1989.
Zaccarini 2018
M. Zaccarini, The Fate of the Lawgiver: The Invention of the Reforms of Ephialtes and the Patrios Politeia, Historia 67.4 (2018), 495-512.
https://doi.org/10.25162/historia-2018-0020
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7358/erga-2023-001-caes
Copyright (©) 2023 Mirko Canevaro – Editorial format and Graphical layout: copyright (©) LED Edizioni Universitarie
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Announcements
Erga/Logoi accepts books for review
The books are to be sent to the Executive Editor
Call for papers Vol. 13 (2025)
Authors have to read through the Information for Authors and the Author guidelines carefully before beginning the submission process.
Erga-Logoi. Rivista di storia, letteratura, diritto e culture dell'antichità
Registered by Tribunale di Milano (20/09/2012 n. 353)
Online ISSN 2282-3212 - Print ISSN 2280-9678
Executive Editor: Cinzia Bearzot
Editorial Staff: Paolo A. Tuci (Coordinator) - Marcello Bertoli - Livia De Martinis - Laura Loddo - Annabella Oranges - Alessandra Valentini
Editorial Board: Gaetano Arena - Ralf Behrwald - Margherita Cassia - Paolo Cesaretti - Bernard Eck - Michele Faraguna - Massimo Gioseffi - Dominique Lenfant - Lauretta Maganzani - Roberto Nicolai - Giovanni Parmeggiani - Marina Polito - Umberto Roberto - Francesca Rohr - Marco Sannazaro - Stefan Schorn - Paolo A. Tuci - Gianpaolo Urso - José Vela Tejada - Robert Wallace
Emeritus Editorial Board: Serena Bianchetti - Giovannella Cresci - Lia Raffaella Cresci - Ugo Fantasia - Franca Landucci - Rosalia Marino - Riccardo Vattuone
© 2001 LED Edizioni Universitarie di Lettere Economia Diritto