Email this article La storia come mezzo: l’Odisseo mediatore di Polibio
Abstract
The text inquires into the meaning of Polybius’ references to Odysseus advancing the hypothesis of reconstructive mediation. The text’s two aims are first to delimit Polybius’ concept of mediation, then to use it to discuss possible meanings from the explicit association between Polybius himself and Odysseus in the Histories. §§ 2. and 3. analyze two sets of Polybius’ snippets through complementary approaches (M. Jay’s intellectual history, C. Romano’s hermeneutics, J. Thornton’s diplomatic perspective): the first one, on history’s mediative function, is discussed in the light of Polybius’ own theoretical
statements in book XII; the second one, centered on his explicit mentions to Odysseus, advances the hypothesis of political mediation perceptible in Polybius’ mediative attitudes. The conclusions (§ 4.) argue the coherence between discoursive and political mediations in two ways: reconstructive (by investigating a Polibian meaning about writing history) and historiographical (by drawing a topical comparison with Thucydides).
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Astin 1967 – A.E. Astin, Scipio Aemilianus, Oxford 1967.
Baronowski 2011 – D.W. Baronowski, Polybius and Roman Imperialism, London 2011.
Brouwer 2011 – R. Brouwer, Polybius and Stoic «Tyche», GRBS 51 (2011), 111-132.
Champion 2004 – C.B. Champion, Cultural Politics in Polybius’s «Histories», Berkeley - Los Angeles - London 2004.
Croce 19546 – B. Croce, La storia come pensiero e come azione, Bari 19546.
Davidson 1991 – J. Davidson, The gaze in Polybius’ «Histories», JRS 81 (1991), 10-24.
Dorandi 1989 – T. Dorandi, Contributo epigrafico alla cronologia di Panezio, ZPE 79 (1989), 87-92.
Eckstein 1995 – A.E. Eckstein, Moral Vision in the «Histories» of Polybius, Berkeley - Los Angeles - London 1995.
Eco 2012 – U. Eco, Di un realismo negativo, in M. de Caro - M. Ferraris (a cura di), Bentornata realtà. Il nuovo realismo in discussione, Torino 2012.
Erskine 2001 – A. Erskine, Troy between Greece and Rome. Local Tradition and Imperial Power, Oxford 2001.
Erskine 2012 – A. Erskine, Polybius among the Romans: Life in the Cyclop’s Cave, in C. Smith - L. M. Yarrow (eds.), Imperialism, Cultural Politics, and Polybius, Oxford 2012, 17-32.
Goldberg 1995 – S.M. Goldberg, Epic in Republican Rome, New York - Oxford 1995.
Gruen 1993 – E. Gruen, Culture and National Identity in Republican Rome, Ithaca - New York 1993.
Hartog 2001 – F. Hartog, Memories of Odysseus: Frontier Tales from Ancient Greece, Chigago 2001 (Mémoire d’Ulysse. Récits sur la frontière en Grèce ancienne, Paris 1996).
Haug 1854 – M. Haug, Die Quelle Plutarchs in den Lebensbeschreibungen der Griechen, Tübingen 1854.
Heeren 1820 – A.H.L. Heeren, De fontibus et auctoritate «Vitarum paralelarum» Plutarchi. Commentationes quatuor, Gottingae 1820.
Hirzel 1882 – R. Hirzel, Untersuchung zu Cicero’s philosophischen schriften, II.1, Leipzig 1882.
Isnardi 1955 – M. Isnardi, ΤΕΧΝΗ e ΗΘΟΣ nella metodologia storiografica di Polibio, SCO 3 (1955) 102-110.
Jay 2011 – M. Jay, Historical Explanation and the Event: Reflections on the Limits of Contextualization, New Literary History 42 (2011) 557-571.
Jay 2013 – M. Jay, Intention and Irony: The Missed Encounter between Hayden White and Quentin Skinner, H&T 52 (2013), 32-48.
Livingstone 2004 – I. Livingstone, A Linguistic Commentary on Livius Andronicus, New York - London 2004.
Longley 2012 – G. Longley, Thucydides, Polybius, and Human Nature, in C. Smith - L.M. Yarrow (eds.), Imperialism, Cultural Politics, and Polybius, Oxford 2012, 68-84.
Löwy 2001 – M. Löwy, Walter Benjamin: avertissement d’incendie. Une lecture des thèses «Sur le concept d’histoire», Paris 2001.
Malkin 1998 – I. Malkin, The Returns of Odysseus. Colonization and Ethnicity, Berkeley - Los Angeles - London 1998.
Marincola 2007 – J. Marincola, Odysseus and the Historians, Syllecta Classica 18 (2007), 1-79.
Mauersberger 2006 – A. Mauersberger, Polybios-lexikon, I.4, Berlin 2006.
McGing 2010 – B. McGing, Polybius’ «Histories» (Oxford Approaches to Classical Literature), Oxford 2010.
Momigliano 1980 – A. Momigliano, The Historian’s Skin, in A. Momigliano, Sesto contributo alla storia degli studi classici e del mondo antico, I, Roma 1980, 77-88.
Musti 1978 – D. Musti, Polibio e l’imperialismo romano, Napoli 1978.
Musti 2001-2006 – Polibio, Storie, I-VIII, a cura di D. Musti, trad. di M. Mari - F. Canali De Rossi - A.L. Santarelli, note di J. Thornton, Milano 2001-2006.
Nissen 1863 – H. Nissen, Kritische Untersuchungen über die Quellen der vierten und fünften Dekade des Livius, Berlin 1863.
Pédech 1951 – P. Pédech, Polybe et l’<éloge de Philopoemen>, REG 64 (1951), 82-103.
Pédech 1961 – Polybe, Histoires. Livre XII, éd. par P. Pédech, Paris 1961.
Pédech 1964 – P. Pédech, La méthode historique de Polybe, Paris 1964.
Pfeiffer 1968 – R.C.F.O. Pfeiffer, History of Classical Scholarship. From the Beginnings to the End of the Hellenistic Age, Oxford 1968.
Pires 1998 – F.M. Pires, The Rhetoric of Method (Thucydides I.22 and II.35), AHB 12 (1998), 106-112.
Schweighäuser 1792 – Πολυβίου Μεγαλοπολίτου, Ἱστορίων. Τὰ σωζόμενα, V, ed. I. Schweighäuser, Lipsiae 1792.
Romano 2010 – C. Romano, Compréhension d’un texte et intention d’auteur, in M. Ouelbani (éd.), L’intention, Tunis 2010, 57-84.
Romano 2013 – C. Romano, De la compréhension. Quelques parallèles entre Wittgenstein et la tradition herméneutique, in C. Romano (éd.), Wittgenstein, Paris 2013, 547-598.
Rood 2012 – T. Rood, Polybius, Thucydides, and The First Punic War, in C. Smith - L. M. Yarrow (eds.), Imperialism, Cultural Politics, and Polybius, Oxford 2012, 50-67.
Sacks 1981 – K. Sacks, Polybius on the Writing of History, Berkeley - Los Angeles - London 1981.
Scala 1890 – R. von Scala, Die Studien des Polybios, I, Stuttgart 1890.
Thornton 20012 – J. Thornton, Lo storico, il grammatico, il bandito. Momenti della resistenza Greca all’«Imperium Romanum», Catania, 20012.
Thornton 2013a – J. Thornton, Polibio l’artista, MediterrAnt 16 (2013), 827-842.
Thornton 2013b – J. Thornton, Polybius in Context: The Political Dimension of the «Histories», in B. Gibson - T. Harrisson (eds.), Polybius and His World. Essays in Memory of F.W. Walbank, Oxford 2013, 213-229.
Vercruysse 1990 – M. Vercruysse, Polybe et les épopées homeriques, AncSoc 21 (1990), 293-309.
Walbank 1948 – F.W. Walbank, The Geography of Polybius, C&M (1948), 155-182.
Walbank 1967 – F.W. Walbank, A Historical Commentary on Polybius, II, Oxford 1967.
Walbank 1970 – F.W. Walbank, A Historical Commentary on Polybius, I, Oxford 1970.
Walbank 1972 – F.W. Walbank, Polybius, Berkeley - Los Angeles - London 1972.
Walbank 1979 – F.W. Walbank, A Historical Commentary on Polybius, III, Oxford 1979.
Walbank 1985 – F.W. Walbank, Selected Papers. Studies in Greek and Roman History and Historiography, Cambridge 1985.
Walbank 2002 – F.W. Walbank, Polybius, Rome and the Hellenistic World. Essays and Reflections, Cambridge 2002.
Wunderer 1901 – C. Wunderer, Polybios-Forschungen. Beitrage zur Spracheund Kulturgeschichte, II, Leipzig 1901.
Zetzel 1972 – J.E.G. Zetzel, Cicero and the Scipionic Circle, HSPh 76 (1972), 173-179.
Ziegler 1952 – K. Ziegler, s.v. Polybios (1), in RE 21.2, 1952, 1440-1578.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7358/erga-2015-002-batt
Copyright (©) 2015 Erga-Logoi. Rivista di storia, letteratura, diritto e culture dell'antichità – Editorial format and Graphical layout: copyright (©) LED Edizioni Universitarie
Announcements
Erga/Logoi accepts books for review
The books are to be sent to the Executive Editor
Call for papers Vol. 13 (2025)
Authors have to read through the Information for Authors and the Author guidelines carefully before beginning the submission process.
Erga-Logoi. Rivista di storia, letteratura, diritto e culture dell'antichità
Registered by Tribunale di Milano (20/09/2012 n. 353)
Online ISSN 2282-3212 - Print ISSN 2280-9678
Executive Editor: Cinzia Bearzot
Editorial Staff: Paolo A. Tuci (Coordinator) - Marcello Bertoli - Livia De Martinis - Laura Loddo - Annabella Oranges - Alessandra Valentini
Editorial Board: Gaetano Arena - Ralf Behrwald - Margherita Cassia - Paolo Cesaretti - Bernard Eck - Michele Faraguna - Massimo Gioseffi - Dominique Lenfant - Lauretta Maganzani - Roberto Nicolai - Giovanni Parmeggiani - Marina Polito - Umberto Roberto - Francesca Rohr - Marco Sannazaro - Stefan Schorn - Paolo A. Tuci - Gianpaolo Urso - José Vela Tejada - Robert Wallace
Emeritus Editorial Board: Serena Bianchetti - Giovannella Cresci - Lia Raffaella Cresci - Ugo Fantasia - Franca Landucci - Rosalia Marino - Riccardo Vattuone
© 2001 LED Edizioni Universitarie di Lettere Economia Diritto