Led On Line
Presentazione - About us
Novita' - What's new
Lededizioni Home Page Ricerca - Search
Catalogo - Catalogue
Per contattarci - Contacts
Per gli Autori - For the Authors
Statistiche - Statistics
Cookie Policy
Privacy Policy

A study in white: medicine and crime according to Sherlock Holmes

Michele Lopez


Sherlock Holmes is described by his biographer as being in possession of an “immense knowledge” of criminal history. He substantiates this claim by frequent casual references to particular criminal cases. Dr. William Palmer and Dr. Edward Pritchard, two infamous examples of “killer doctors”, are cited by the detective as typical specimens of what heights – or depths – a murderer can reach when he has the “nerve and knowledge” granted by a scientific medical training. We shall give a brief biographical sketch of these two illustrious gentlemen and we will show that Holmes’ fears are not without fundament – indeed, the medical profession has given more than its fair share of murderers. The scientific method of diagnostic medicine, which can be so useful in criminal detection, has proven to be very useful also to many a ruthless and cunning assassin. Holmes, who was ahead of his time in combining medical semeiotics and detective work, was also prophetic in pointing out how terrible a threat to society a criminal doctor can be.

Full Text:



Augias, C. (2004), “Sherlock Holmes: il medico della società”, in Guerra e Solito (2004), 5-7.

Baldini, M. (1998), Karl Popper e Sherlock Holmes: l’epistemologo, il detective, il medico, lo storico e lo scienziato, Roma, Armando Editore.

Bell, J. (1892), “Mr. Sherlock Holmes”, in Doyle (1892), 8-11.

Doyle, A.C. (1892), A study in scarlet, London, Ward, Lock & Co.

Doyle, A.C. (1981), The Complete Sherlock Holmes, Harmondsworth, Penguin.

Fletcher, G. (1925), The life and career of Dr. William Palmer of Rugeley, London, T. Fisher Unwin.

Graves, R. (1957), They hanged my saintly Billy, London, Cassell’s.

Guerra, S. e E. Solito (2004), Il diciottesimo scalino. L’enciclopedia di Sherlock Holmes, Milano, Delos Books.

Kinnell, H. (2000), “Serial homicide by doctors: Shipman in perspective”. British Medical Journal, 321: 1594-7.

Macleod, N. (1876), Memoir of Norman Macleod, D.D., London, Daldy, Isbister & Co.

Old Bailey Proceedings Online, May 1856, trial of William Palmer (t18560514-490), http://www.oldbaileyonline.org, accessed 17 November 2008.

Rapezzi, C., Ferrari, R., and Branzi, A. (2005), “White coats and fingerprints: diagnostic reasoning in medicine and investigative methods of fictional detectives”, British Medical Journal, 331: 1491-94.

Roughead, W. (1941a), “Poison in the pantry, or Dr. Pritchard revisited”, in Roughead (1941b): 55-113.

Roughead, W. (1941b), The murderer’s companion, New York, Press of the Readers Club.

Taylor, A.S. (1859), On poisons in relation to medical jurisprudence and medicine, London, Churchill.

Copyright (©) 2014 Linguæ & - Rivista di lingue e culture moderne – Editorial format and Graphical layout: copyright (©) LED Edizioni Universitarie


Linguæ & - Rivista di lingue e culture moderne
Registered by Tribunale di Milano (06/04/2012 n. 185)
Online ISSN 1724-8698 - Print ISSN 2281-8952

Dipartimento di Scienze della Comunicazione, Studi Umanistici e Internazionali: Storia, Culture, Lingue, Letterature, Arti, Media
Università degli Studi di Urbino Carlo Bo

Editor-in-Chief: Roberta Mullini
Editorial Board: Maurizio Ascari - Stefano Beretta - Antonio Bertacca- Tania Collani - Chiara Elefante - Marina Guglielmi - Maryline Heck - Richard Hillman - Reinhard Johler - Stephen Knight - Cesare Mascitelli - Sonia Massai - Aurélie Moioli - Maria de Fátima Silva - Bart Van Den Bossche 

Editorial Staff: Margaret Amatulli - Alessandra Calanchi - Riccardo Donati - Ivo Klaver  - Massimiliano Morini - Antonella Negri - Luca Renzi

Referee List

© 2001 LED Edizioni Universitarie di Lettere Economia Diritto